You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!
The banners on the left side and below do not show for registered users!
If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.
Entertainment ForumTHIS SPACE OPEN FOR ADVERTISEMENT. YOU SHOULD BE ADVERTISING HERE! Entertainment District
Members' movie reviews, Trailers, TV show post-discussions. Warning: Absolutely, do not post links to pirated or illegal download sites!
To be fair it was quite empty in the books, but not THIS empty. Probably more like what they showed when Tyrion was there in season 1.
The following isn't really a spoiler, but tells how the books are different:
Spoiler!
In the books, they framed a bard for the murder, and locked him up in that dungeon they had Tyrion in. As you can guess, that made for a more interesting scene, and had a stronger effect on Sansa's character as she had to hear him singing in his dungeon (IIRC).
In the show, he just gets away with it I suppose, since nobody was around when it happened
To be fair it was quite empty in the books, but not THIS empty. Probably more like what they showed when Tyrion was there in season 1.
The following isn't really a spoiler, but tells how the books are different:
Spoiler!
In the books, they framed a bard for the murder, and locked him up in that dungeon they had Tyrion in. As you can guess, that made for a more interesting scene, and had a stronger effect on Sansa's character as she had to hear him singing in his dungeon (IIRC).
In the show, he just gets away with it I suppose, since nobody was around when it happened
I havn't read the books, and I talk about some the differences between the books and the movie ** up to the point of where the TV shows are at** with my friends as to see what has changed.
I can understand and agree with what HBO is doing. It seems like in the book they have way more characters and more scenes that are not shown in the movies.
I think with the way the show works, they just dont have enough time/money to show all these scenes as well as cast more characters, some of which may deter a lot of audience members as theres already a lot of side plots to begin with. It can get confusing for the non-hardcore fans.
Also I like how HBO cuts out a lot of the unnecessary gore and sadistic scenes that the book has just for the sake of being gory and not really adding vlaue. I like how they imply a lot of the "painful" scenes instead of showing it to us. This is good for me b/c my girlfriend also watches the show.
Again, I havnt read the books and am just relying on what my friends are telling me from the books.
I havn't read the books, and I talk about some the differences between the books and the movie ** up to the point of where the TV shows are at** with my friends as to see what has changed.
I can understand and agree with what HBO is doing. It seems like in the book they have way more characters and more scenes that are not shown in the movies.
I think with the way the show works, they just dont have enough time/money to show all these scenes as well as cast more characters, some of which may deter a lot of audience members as theres already a lot of side plots to begin with. It can get confusing for the non-hardcore fans.
Also I like how HBO cuts out a lot of the unnecessary gore and sadistic scenes that the book has just for the sake of being gory and not really adding vlaue. I like how they imply a lot of the "painful" scenes instead of showing it to us. This is good for me b/c my girlfriend also watches the show.
Again, I havnt read the books and am just relying on what my friends are telling me from the books.
I get that they have to make a lot of changes, and like I said, many of them are fine. Some of them are pretty lame though, particularly the Eerie being empty, and the whole Theon Greyjoy thing. What he goes through is SO much crazier in the books, and that's all I'll say
I am only bringing up things that I think would make the show much better, not necessarily complaining about it not being accurate enough. I don't care how accurate it is to the books, except for when things are significantly worse. The Danaerys storyline is pretty much a kindergarten version of the books, but if they tried to be 100% accurate each episode would be 2 hours longer
if the mountain dies which I dont know it looked to me like he fell on his back and died right after crushing dudes skull..... anyway my question is if the mountain dies as well what's the verdict for Tyrion then ??
does he walk free, or still get sentenced to death ?
__________________ (oO:::\___/:::Oo) (DPE-wheels) // Satin Cocaine White
I only answer to my username, my real name is Irrelevant!
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: CELICAland
Posts: 25,668
Thanked 10,388 Times in 3,914 Posts
Failed 1,390 Times in 625 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by G-spec
Spoiler!
if the mountain dies which I dont know it looked to me like he fell on his back and died right after crushing dudes skull..... anyway my question is if the mountain dies as well what's the verdict for Tyrion then ??
does he walk free, or still get sentenced to death ?
I was thinking that too so I couldn't wait and went to read up what happened in the book
the one thing im starting to hate about the show is how they always lead us on with all these possible stark reunions, but it never happens. like the many possible jon snow and bran reunions, and the sansa and arya possible reunions.
You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!
The banners on the left side and below do not show for registered users!
.png "Y U NO...?")
