REVscene Automotive Forum - The Official 2011/2012 Canucks Thread

REVscene Automotive Forum (https://www.revscene.net/forums/)

- Vancouver Off-Topic / Current Events (https://www.revscene.net/forums/vancouver-off-topic-current-events_50/)

- - The Official 2011/2012 Canucks Thread (https://www.revscene.net/forums/647779-official-2011-2012-canucks-thread.html)

You're not much better yourself, M5. Just look at your post history in this thread - you only post when you get a chance to crap on Luongo or when you do the fanboy thing yourself :rolleyes:

Agree with Ronin.

IMO I don't think starting cory is AV's decision.

Quote:

Originally Posted by jayare604 (Post 7891342)

It is partially MG's fault for handing out NTCs like candy

Most core players who have signed contracts in the last 6 or 7 years have NTC's. No matter where Luongo signed at that time he would have gotten a NTC.

If we could sign Corey for another 3 @ 3 per I think that would be completely feasible, but who knows if either side would go for that

I love that the Hawks lost Hossa. That shit came full circle back to them, didn't it?
Last PO, Torres eliminates Seabrook. This season, Keith eliminates DSedin, gets 5 games for it (like it mattered) and makes DSedin almost miss R1 of PO.
Unfortunately for Torres, he's suspended indefinitely lol. I hope the Coyotes clean them out.

Judgment day for Van and Pittsburgh. I hope they both steal a game. Canucks deserve more than just R1 and Pittsburgh, well, they have the best player in the league.

Schneids or Luo, either way I cannot wait for todays game. Go Canucks go!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ronin (Post 7891347)

You'd think people would be happy we have two awesome goalies.

unfortunately, it's a luxury most fans don't understand in this city. lu and schnu have always supported each other; they want the TEAM to win. the media really has done their job by instilling doubt and controversy (where there is none) into the minds of some fans.

whatever. cory is in, we all want the canucks to win. well, except for Hondaracer because he'd rather see the team lose to prove his point. True fan right there :rolleyes:

Quote:

Originally Posted by MG1 (Post 7891258)

^^^^That poster is laminated and is one of my most precious of Canuck memorabilia.

What a team that was. Jim Robson, the voice of the Canucks...........

I hate you for all of eternity, Messier....... and Keenan, of course. That 94 team should have won the cup. They, of any team, should have won it. Every time I see the "Heart and Soul" poster of Linden hugging McLean, I weep. Perhaps that's why I don't have it in my collection.

Jim Robson was one of the best play-by-play guys of his generation. Quite possibly in the Top 10 in the history of the game.

Trevor was a shadow of his former self during his second stint here. If only some of the youngsters here would have grown up watching him in his prime. He was never a gifted scorer, but when he collected the puck in his zone with a full head of steam...

All this talk about dirty hits, and blown officiating is a little bit off-centre, IMHO. The 80s and 90s were just as bad with bench clearing brawls and dirty players like Ulf Samuelsson, Claude Lemieux, etc.

And players didn't hide behind visors. :troll:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hondaracer (Post 7891368)

If we could sign Corey for another 3 @ 3 per I think that would be completely feasible, but who knows if either side would go for that

yeah I'm sure canucks would be more than happy to do that, but I don't think cory goes for that, that deal is basically exactly what corey crawford got from the hawks off an above average regular season at best. He was basically promised the starting gig as well in Chi, where as in Van, its going to be another goalie tandem ? I don't think corey wants to be 1A/1B for another 3 years of his prime years.

I predict Juice (03) is going to lose it tonight. Any takers?

There is an article on nhl.com about goaltender rotation in the playoffs.

I am not questioning whether AV is making the right decision with choosing Schneider to start game 4.

Who am I to second guess an NHL coach when I've never coached a professional game in my life, let alone play in a pro hockey game?

Just win!

The posts on this thread about starting Luongo or Schneider tonight have been an interesting read.

Here's the article: Goalie rotation in playoffs could be popular choice - NHL.com - The Stanley Cup

Quote:

Originally Posted by 7seven (Post 7889997)

hahaha thought this was hilarious, playoff headgames

Todd Bertuzzi Would Like The Predators To Get Their Own Ping-Pong Table - Motown Lowdown - SB Nation Detroit

http://i.imgur.com/mHc5v.gif

Wow, a potential franchise changing decision to start Schneids over Lu, regardless if we win or lose tonight.

Lu's been saying all the right things about putting the team first and he's been extremely supportive of Schneids, but this is a clear message by the coaching staff that Schneids is our new #1. You absolutely have to go with your #1 in the biggest game of the year unless he is not your #1 anymore or he is unable to play.

Imagine being the #1 guy at work, about to embark on the most important project of the year for your company and you are asked to step aside for someone else. Would you still want to work for that company? Would you still be able to give it your best? Would your heart still be in it, especially if you felt like you were still at the top of your game? As a member of management, would you believe that this person would be unaffected by your decision, remain as motivated as before, and still give you 110%?

Regardless if they fire AV or trade Schneids, Lu's time with the Canucks is done. Anything less than that and it would be a total failure by management. You simply cannot tell your #1 that he's #2 now, trade the new #1 and tell your #2 that he's #1 again and expect him to be unaffected. Human beings do not work that way, especially those that are top performers.

It will be one hell of an off season!

Starting Cory Schneider sure to have aftershocks. But a Luongo trade won’t be easy | The Province

Quote:

LOS ANGLES – In the win-or-go-home game, the Canucks will go with their backup.

Well, you can actually stop calling Cory Schneider the backup. Two playoff starts in a row means those days are behind him.

In a decision that is sure to have lasting implications, head coach Alain Vigneault will start Schneider instead of Roberto Luongo, once the captain and the core of the team.
“Whichever decision I made would have been the right one,” Vigneault said. “But without getting into the specifics of why Cory is playing tonight, I’m confident he’s going to have a good game.”

Vigneault had a face-to-face meeting with both goalies Tuesday night. His decision to go down Marblehead Road could change the face of the franchise.
Luongo chose not talk with media, but this will be hard for him to deal with. He was the starter for Game 1 of the playoffs. He played two games, was great at points, consistently good and made just a handful of mistakes.
This isn’t about his play. This is about the team believing that Schneider is better. And if the team feels that way now, why didn’t it feel that way to start the postseason?

It’s a good question. And will be reversed if Schneider wins tonight and the Cancuks go back to Luongo for Game 5. Don’t for a second think that’s not possible.

For now, through no fault of his own, Luongo has lost his spot as the team’s definitive No. 1 goalie. It’s hard to imagine him wanting to play another year in Vancouver under these circumstances.

Why would he want to come back and split the position, or worse be resigned to being the backup, if Schneider does prove he really is better?

The Canucks took away Luongo’s goalie coach Ian Clark a couple of years ago. They reduced his workload dramatically, even though he has always said he loves to play. And now, he’s benched for the two biggest games of the year, a decision which had to involve GM Mike Gillis with strong input from goalie coach Rollie Melanson.

So to sum up, they fired his coach, cut his games and took away his job in the playoffs, which he lives for. Being a pround man, at some point he’s going to say enough is enough.

“I’m not surprised at all,” Schneider said. “Nothing surprises us anymore. We both have to be ready for anything.
“After playing last game, I thought there was a chance I would play again.
“We’re both professionals and grown men. We can handle anything they decide.”

Moving forward with Schneider tonight is yet another clue they are planning move forward with him next year.
A Luongo trade will not be easy. If he does tell the team he wants out, he’ll select a few destinations for the Canucks to choose from. Tampa would be on the list, probably Florida and some wild cards, maybe Detroit. It won’t be long.
Luongo is singed until 2022. That’s ten more years.
Coming back with both goalies next year can’t be totally ruled out, but it seems terribly unlikely right now.

If Luongo is gone, life will change for Schneider who would be the starter for the first time in his NHL career.
“I’ve been a starter at other levels, I played 60 games in Manitoba,” Schneider said. “I understand, it’s not the NHL. But you have the same ups and downs in that season as you would in any season.
“It’s harder to be perfect over more games.”
And we all know Vancouver demands their goalies be perfect!

Both goalies played well, Cory only let in 1 goal so he gets the start. Doesn't mean they've lost confidence in Lu. Pretty simple really.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nodnarb (Post 7891426)

Both goalies played well, Cory only let in 1 goal so he gets the start. Doesn't mean they've lost confidence in Lu. Pretty simple really.

This should be the bottom line.

Both are great goalies for sure

but LU = No consistency, he might shit his pant at a biggest game

Cory on the other side proven consistency, just dont cramp out

Honestly, goal tending this series wasn't what bothered or worried me the most. It's rare that I feel that way too, based on last years run. We're good to go if we stop taking these stupid avoidable penalties and capitalized on scoring chances during the PP. That's it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ronin (Post 7891347)

You'd think people would be happy we have two awesome goalies.

^THIS

what we have here is people who cant sit down and think for themselves or give an opinion

OH NOESSS CORY STARTING...MEANS LUONGO WONT BE A CANUCK NEXT YEAR. its all speculation or just the media creating a story.

Until all the smoke is cleared, just be happy that BOTH our goalies got us to where we were.

isn't it the same situation in St. Louis

Halak is 1A
Elliot is 1B

therefore

Luongo is 1A
Schnei is 1B

I don't get how starting Schnieder marks the end of the Loungo era in Vancouver. It is simply speculation.

Lots of teams are shifting to a two-goalie system where they like to see a 50-30 game split for the regular season, and if a goalie falters in the playoffs, you go with the other guy. What makes the Canucks interesting is 1) Luongo's contract and NTC 2) Schnieder at the end of his contract. Do the Canucks have a difficult situation coming up this summer? Yes, but Schneider starting tonight doesn't indicate what happens in the off season. Too many variables in play. Will Cory sign for less here and be guarenteed half the regular season games? Will Luongo waive his NTC to move to a team like Tampa? Will other teams want Luongo's contract?

If Canucks somehow win tonight, they dont' play again until Sunday. That's a lot of rest for Dank and whoever else needs it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by darthchilli (Post 7891479)

It's because people know we have 2 very proven and tradable assets that we can flip for help in other facets of the game.

save the speculation for when the canucks playoffs is over in june :troll:

LETS GET HYPED FOR TODAY BOYS

Quote:

Originally Posted by jayare604 (Post 7891342)

It is partially MG's fault for handing out NTCs like candy

Only our core players have NTCs. MG has done a great job. Eight players (Sedins, Kesler, Manny, Bieksa, Hamhuis, Salo and Lu) have NTCs.

If you want to see NTCs handed out like candy, take a look at Calgary before you criticize Gillis, who is easily the best GM we've ever had. Calgary has 11 (...Matt Stajan!?).

Gillis had to give NTCs because all those players took discounts to stay with the Canucks. It's pretty standard to do when a player takes a hometown deal.