Vancouver Auto Chat 2016 VAC Community Head Moderator: Raid3n | |
04-06-2014, 11:14 PM
|
#1 | I WANT MY 10 YEARS BACK FROM RS.net!
Join Date: Mar 2002 Location: ...
Posts: 20,300
Thanked 4,525 Times in 1,357 Posts
Failed 4,505 Times in 971 Posts
| Ferrari embroiled in legal battle over 21-year-old's Facebook page
Ferrari embroiled in legal battle over 21-year-old's Facebook page
By Chris Bruce
Posted Mar 28th 2014 11:31AM
Ferrari is facing a court battle in Switzerland due to alleged copyright infringement over taking over a Facebook fan site. If the suit is successful, it could cost the company millions and harm its reputation on social media.
Sammy Wassem started the Facebook fan page for Ferrari when he was 15 and eventually grew it to over 500,000 followers. In 2009, the company congratulated him on the site's success, but said that "legal issues" forced it to take over the administration, according to Automotive News Europe. Wassem could still use the site, but managers had oversight.
Wassem asked Ferrari for financial compensation to keep working on the page but continued creating content on it for the next four years. Eventually, the company terminated his administration rights. In 2013 he and his father Olivier filed the lawsuit against the business alleging it owes payment over 5,500 hours of work and copyright infringement for taking over the page. They are asking for 10 million Swiss francs ($11.3 million).
Ferrari is counter-suing them for misusing the company's trademark, including allegedly advertising other merchandise on the page and using it to send invitations to Sammy's 18th birthday.
"The issue isn't with Facebook or with our fans but with those who try to use Ferrari's intellectual property to make money out of it," said Stefano Lai, a spokesman for Ferrari to Automotive News Europe.
The case highlights the difficult balance companies have to maintain with social media. Even if Ferrari is right, the fallout from lawsuit could be a loss of fans. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-0...book-page.html http://www.carscoops.com/2014/03/fer...fight-for.html http://jalopnik.com/this-guy-is-piss...ook-1553062551 http://www.bananaip.com/sinapse-blog...-fan-page.html |
| |
04-06-2014, 11:53 PM
|
#2 | RS has made me the bitter person i am today!
Join Date: Feb 2013 Location: Vancouver
Posts: 4,865
Thanked 7,763 Times in 2,315 Posts
Failed 409 Times in 181 Posts
|
Out of curiosity what is the "content" this kid created?
If it is as I suspect and the kid simply stole pictures from google and other sources and posted them on a fan page he created, then I see no reason this kid should see any sort of payout.
(this is me speaking from a fair and logical standpoint not a legal standpoint, what Ferrari did could very well be illegal)
EDIT: Just looked this up furthur, and thought about it a bit more.
This kid does actually deserve nothing IMO, they tried to negotiate with Ferrari in 2009 when the page was first taken over, they did not get the terms they wanted. After that they kept working on the page purely out of their own goodwill.
Ferrari is a trademarked name, and the Wassems should have never made a FB page under that name anyway.
Also as someone else pointed out 5500 hours for 11 million means this kid is making aprox $2000/hr. I had no idea copying and pasting other photographers work was meant to be more lucrative than the actual person taking the pictures.
Last edited by meme405; 04-07-2014 at 12:00 AM.
|
| |
04-07-2014, 12:39 AM
|
#3 | RS.net, helping ugly ppl have sex since 2001
Join Date: Feb 2011 Location: Richmond
Posts: 8,459
Thanked 14,912 Times in 3,896 Posts
Failed 471 Times in 216 Posts
|
I disagree. He may deserve the equal payout in terms of the amount of hours he managed the Facebook page AFTER ferrari demanded ownership. Thus he became a low-level employee and contined to advertise and support the brand via social media. Posted via RS Mobile |
| |
04-07-2014, 08:19 AM
|
#4 | My homepage has been set to RS
Join Date: Feb 2002
Posts: 2,092
Thanked 485 Times in 149 Posts
Failed 80 Times in 15 Posts
| Posted via RS Mobile |
| |
04-07-2014, 08:33 AM
|
#5 | OMGWTFBBQ is a common word I say everyday
Join Date: Jul 2012 Location: BC
Posts: 5,239
Thanked 4,905 Times in 1,655 Posts
Failed 331 Times in 171 Posts
|
I feel he deserves something, but 5500/hour? What an idiot.
__________________ 2021 F150 Platinum FX4 2021 Mustang GT PP1 6MT |
| |
04-07-2014, 08:56 AM
|
#6 | OMGWTFBBQ is a common word I say everyday
Join Date: Aug 2001 Location: Vancouver
Posts: 5,236
Thanked 169 Times in 44 Posts
Failed 5 Times in 5 Posts
| Quote:
Originally Posted by dared3vil0 I feel he deserves something, but 5500/hour? What an idiot. | 5,500 hours, not per hour
|
| |
04-07-2014, 09:01 AM
|
#7 | I contribute to threads in the offtopic forum
Join Date: Jun 2012 Location: Vancouver
Posts: 2,737
Thanked 3,242 Times in 861 Posts
Failed 136 Times in 59 Posts
|
11.3mil/5,500hours = $2055/hr?
Maths am I doin it rite
|
| |
04-07-2014, 02:33 PM
|
#8 | I WANT MY 10 YEARS BACK FROM RS.net!
Join Date: Mar 2002 Location: ...
Posts: 20,300
Thanked 4,525 Times in 1,357 Posts
Failed 4,505 Times in 971 Posts
|
$2000+/hr for posting things on Facebook is ridiculous.
I bet he exaggerated the 5500 hrs too, it probably was 550 hrs.
|
| |
04-07-2014, 02:34 PM
|
#9 | RS has made me the bitter person i am today!
Join Date: Feb 2013 Location: Vancouver
Posts: 4,865
Thanked 7,763 Times in 2,315 Posts
Failed 409 Times in 181 Posts
| Quote:
Originally Posted by 320icar I disagree. He may deserve the equal payout in terms of the amount of hours he managed the Facebook page AFTER ferrari demanded ownership. Thus he became a low-level employee and contined to advertise and support the brand via social media. Posted via RS Mobile | I disagree, in 2009 the Wassems tried to negotiate a contract with Ferrari and Ferrari flat out refused any sort of compensation or anything for that page.
At that point if the Wassems were unhappy they should have pursued legal action against Ferrari regarding control of the page (which they clearly would have lost).
Going after Ferrari now for those hours makes no sense.
A real life example (albeit simplified):
I apply for a job as a security person for a jewellery store, the jewellery store says they have no openings and do not hire me. Then I go buy a security jacket of my own and stand outside the jewellery store day after day for years. After 5 years the jewellery store finally tells me to get the fuck off their property, then I go and try to sue the jewellery store for the income they never paid me for my services. Would that make any sense?
And before anyone quotes the BC employment standards act to me, or the Quantum Meruit Law, please just don't it does not apply when the individual expressly denied your services.
Again if the Wassems even wanted this to be taken remotely seriously they would have valued their 15 year old kids hourly rate at a more reasonable amount than upwards of $2000/hr.
Instead they are making wildly idiotic attempts at crazy valuations in an attempt to get as much publicity and slander Ferrari as much as possible in the hopes that Ferrari will just settle to get past this bullshit.
I for one can't stand people that try to use the public eye to extort money out of large corporations, and I sincerely hope Ferrari doesn't settle and instead takes the Wassems to the cleaners. My main fear is the bad precedent something like this could send to others if the Wassems do make a penny.
I could only imagine the number of people making pages in other companies names and such then in the future trying to extort money out of said companies.
Last edited by meme405; 04-07-2014 at 02:44 PM.
|
| |
04-07-2014, 02:47 PM
|
#10 | RS has made me the bitter person i am today!
Join Date: Feb 2013 Location: Vancouver
Posts: 4,865
Thanked 7,763 Times in 2,315 Posts
Failed 409 Times in 181 Posts
|
I also have to ask again, exactly what content was this kid creating for the page?
I can understand if he was shooting pictures and videos, but I don't believe thats the case, Instead he was simply stealing other peoples work, and posting their pictures and information on his page.
If anything the photographers work who he stole without giving due credit (which I assume in a lot of cases he did not do), should be the ones suing the pants off this kid.
|
| |
04-07-2014, 03:03 PM
|
#11 | RS.net, helping ugly ppl have sex since 2001
Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: Vancouver
Posts: 9,466
Thanked 3,731 Times in 1,833 Posts
Failed 693 Times in 217 Posts
| Quote:
Originally Posted by meme405 I also have to ask again, exactly what content was this kid creating for the page?
I can understand if he was shooting pictures and videos, but I don't believe thats the case, Instead he was simply stealing other peoples work, and posting their pictures and information on his page.
If anything the photographers work who he stole without giving due credit (which I assume in a lot of cases he did not do), should be the ones suing the pants off this kid. | I agree. Forza Ferrari! It's crazy with what people can do within the justice system these days, launching lawsuits left, right, and center, to get compensation and also slowing down the justice system from helping people.
Ferrari's Prancing Horse needs to give this kid a kick in the ass with their team of lawyers.
__________________
Go Canucks go!
|
| |
04-07-2014, 03:09 PM
|
#12 | I told him no, what y'all do?
Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Vancouver
Posts: 10,179
Thanked 6,029 Times in 2,620 Posts
Failed 105 Times in 67 Posts
|
he should have just asked for a ferrari for his troubles
__________________ Feedback http://www.revscene.net/forums/showthread.php?t=611711 Quote: Greenstoner 1 rat shit ruins the whole congee originalhypa You cannot live the life of a whore and expect a monument to your chastity | Quote:
[22-12, 08:51]mellomandidnt think and went in straight..scrapped like a bitch
[17-09, 12:07]FastAnna glowjob
[17-09, 12:08]FastAnna I like dat
| |
| |
04-07-2014, 03:15 PM
|
#13 | RS.net, helping ugly ppl have sex since 2001
Join Date: Feb 2011 Location: Richmond
Posts: 8,459
Thanked 14,912 Times in 3,896 Posts
Failed 471 Times in 216 Posts
| Quote:
Originally Posted by meme405 | Ah sorry. I don't think i totally understood the situation. Yes they should have pursued legal action years ago. Doing so now is at bit snooze you lose. And asking 11 mil is ludicrous, i don't think anyone is disagreeing that point. Posted via RS Mobile |
| |
04-07-2014, 04:11 PM
|
#14 | RS.net, where our google ads make absolutely no sense!
Join Date: Mar 2011 Location: Richmond
Posts: 916
Thanked 692 Times in 227 Posts
Failed 68 Times in 25 Posts
|
If the Wassem's generated even a single penny from the site, they will have violated any international fair use acts and will lose any right to the site's trademarked content.
tbh, the only crutch that the Wassems has are trying to get the public's side. Civil legal battles are war of attrition, Ferrari's legal team will wring them dry.
|
| |
04-07-2014, 04:14 PM
|
#15 | RS has made me the bitter person i am today!
Join Date: Feb 2013 Location: Vancouver
Posts: 4,865
Thanked 7,763 Times in 2,315 Posts
Failed 409 Times in 181 Posts
| Quote:
Originally Posted by 320icar Ah sorry. I don't think i totally understood the situation. Yes they should have pursued legal action years ago. Doing so now is at bit snooze you lose. And asking 11 mil is ludicrous, i don't think anyone is disagreeing that point. Posted via RS Mobile | No need to apologize. The case is confusing at best, because of the stupid timeline and poor reporting by most news agencies (I blame this almost solely on the race for news sites to gain hits).
|
| |
04-09-2014, 10:12 AM
|
#16 | To me, there is the Internet and there is RS
Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Okanagan
Posts: 16,814
Thanked 9,491 Times in 4,144 Posts
Failed 429 Times in 227 Posts
| Quote:
Originally Posted by Timpo Sammy Wassem started the Facebook fan page for Ferrari when he was 15 and eventually grew it to over 500,000 followers. In 2009, the company congratulated him on the site's success, but said that "legal issues" forced it to take over the administration, according to Automotive News Europe. Wassem could still use the site, but managers had oversight. | This makes sense, when something grows to that size it's something the company should be controlling as it's become more than just a simple fan page. Quote:
Originally Posted by Timpo Wassem asked Ferrari for financial compensation to keep working on the page but continued creating content on it for the next four years. Eventually, the company terminated his administration rights. | I'm not sure what he was thinking here, he should've asked Ferrari for a small sum for the work he had already done, I can't think of any original content that he could create for the page after Ferrari took over. Quote:
Originally Posted by Timpo In 2013 he and his father Olivier filed the lawsuit against the business alleging it owes payment over 5,500 hours of work and copyright infringement for taking over the page. They are asking for 10 million Swiss francs ($11.3 million). | Payment for work they never asked him to do? I'm guessing part of the $11.3M is for the copyright infringement but I'm curious as to what copywritten content he was producing. Quote:
Originally Posted by Timpo Ferrari is counter-suing them for misusing the company's trademark, including allegedly advertising other merchandise on the page and using it to send invitations to Sammy's 18th birthday.
"The issue isn't with Facebook or with our fans but with those who try to use Ferrari's intellectual property to make money out of it," said Stefano Lai, a spokesman for Ferrari to Automotive News Europe. | I'm curious if the other merchandise is for legitimate product or just those stupid spammers that join facebook groups?
__________________ 1991 Toyota Celica GTFour RC // 2007 Toyota Rav4 V6 // 2000 Jeep Grand Cherokee
1992 Toyota Celica GT-S ["sold"] \\ 2007 Jeep Grand Cherokee CRD [sold] \\ 2000 Jeep Cherokee [sold] \\ 1997 Honda Prelude [sold] \\ 1992 Jeep YJ [sold/crashed] \\ 1987 Mazda RX-7 [sold] \\ 1987 Toyota Celica GT-S [crushed] Quote:
Originally Posted by maksimizer half those dudes are hotter than ,my GF. | Quote:
Originally Posted by RevYouUp reading this thread is like waiting for goku to charge up a spirit bomb in dragon ball z | Quote:
Originally Posted by Good_KarMa OH thank god. I thought u had sex with my wife. :cry: | |
| | |
Posting Rules
| You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts HTML code is Off | | | All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:31 PM. |