REVscene Automotive Forum

REVscene Automotive Forum (https://www.revscene.net/forums/)
-   Vancouver Off-Topic / Current Events (https://www.revscene.net/forums/vancouver-off-topic-current-events_50/)
-   -   Health trackers (https://www.revscene.net/forums/717983-health-trackers.html)

blkgsr 03-19-2025 12:24 PM

Health trackers
 
Who has a watch/ring/band health tracker?

Whoop, oura ring, apple watch, garmin, fitbit etc

I don't wear a watch or ring normally. I don't want to wear a device like that and ideally would prefer a whoop type device.

I primarily want this for sleeping (sleep apnea etc). I don't plan on wearing it for working out but if I did a ring wouldn't be ideal.

The issue with the whoop is the monthly subscription. Have to renew after 12months as the initial subscription includes the device.

Same with the oura ring where you have to buy it and also the subscription but they are supposed to be one of the better options for sleep tracking.

Apple watch is an option, but again, don't want to have a watch and I don't have an Iphone.

68style 03-19-2025 12:43 PM

Sounds like you need an implant!

donk. 03-19-2025 04:09 PM

Wasting your money for sleep apnea.
The only way is to sleep in a lab, or take home specific equipment from a test center.

Watch - Those are just marketing gimmicks for you to buy their shit. Same as those "50$ desk air conditioners" you see on temu

Hehe 03-19-2025 08:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by blkgsr (Post 9169729)
Who has a watch/ring/band health tracker?

Whoop, oura ring, apple watch, garmin, fitbit etc

I don't wear a watch or ring normally. I don't want to wear a device like that and ideally would prefer a whoop type device.

I primarily want this for sleeping (sleep apnea etc). I don't plan on wearing it for working out but if I did a ring wouldn't be ideal.

The issue with the whoop is the monthly subscription. Have to renew after 12months as the initial subscription includes the device.

Same with the oura ring where you have to buy it and also the subscription but they are supposed to be one of the better options for sleep tracking.

Apple watch is an option, but again, don't want to have a watch and I don't have an Iphone.

For sleep apnea, you have to see what you actually have. Some people have genuine problem with their breathing while they sleep and they need cpap to correct it. I went to the best sleep clinic in Taiwan when I was there last year as my snoring has been getting worse and I was feeling less energetic because of it.

The doctor ran a full test while I was sleeping there, and he said I was actually ok and cpap wouldn't help me much. He prescribed a head strap to help with my breathing as it's more about the muscles not relaxing/tightening as I needed as I age. Did that and it helped immensely.

Many sleeping doctors would just push a cpap to you because they make a lot of money of it. Thus, do find a good doctor if you are heading for one.

N.V.M. 03-20-2025 06:01 AM

I wear a Fitbit Sense, and have the app on my phone to collect data.

I also wear a heart monitor when I work out on my rowing machine. when I'm done the rowing machine sends that data, plus my rowing stats to my Fitbit app.

I have a smart scale, and the app for that automatically records my weight, and sends it to my Fitbit.

now if I could get my BP machine's app to connect to my Fitbit...

blkgsr 03-20-2025 11:10 AM

i already know i have mild/moderate sleep apnea, i'm not expecting a device to tell me that what i want is to track my o2 and heart rate levels while i sleep

HEHE can you give me more information about this head band?

after doing the sleep test they told me on my side i have about 8 episodes per hour vs on my back at 16/hr

donk. 03-20-2025 01:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by blkgsr (Post 9169880)
after doing the sleep test they told me on my side i have about 8 episodes per hour vs on my back at 16/hr

Sounds like you snore on your back disrupting your sleep, could try nose magnets for the low cost of 15$

blkgsr 03-20-2025 02:17 PM

my wife says i don't really snore, just breath loudly....what ever that means

i have a referral for the cpap machine from my doctor, i'll try the 30 day trial and see how i feel

being tired all the time sucks

PeanutButter 03-20-2025 02:29 PM

Sleep apnea is measured through a different device. Getting one of these health trackers is not going to give you an accurate assessment for sleep apnea. You'll get sleep data, but sleep apnea is a medical condition that needs a CPAP device for proper intervention.

Garmin has the best information for sleep and activities that are free.

Honestly, if you're not going to use it for activities, I don't think it's even necessary.

If you golf, get the Garmin Venu 3, as you get golf distance data + all other activity tracking + sleep tracking. If you don't care about Golf then you should look at the Garmin vivoactive 5, if you use a Sport Chek VIP code you can save about 25% right now.

I never understood the idea of the whoop, it's essentially a watch body without the benefit of a watch.

I think the only one that appeals to me is the ring as that seems kind of cool, but the subscription for it turns me off.

Your best bet is a garmin watch since you don't have an iPhone.

whitev70r 03-20-2025 02:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by blkgsr (Post 9169880)
i already know i have mild/moderate sleep apnea, i'm not expecting a device to tell me that what i want is to track my o2 and heart rate levels while i sleep

HEHE can you give me more information about this head band?

after doing the sleep test they told me on my side i have about 8 episodes per hour vs on my back at 16/hr

Maybe something like this? I'm guessing

https://i5.walmartimages.com/seo/Sno...0&odnBg=FFFFFF

https://www.walmart.com/ip/Snore-Rel...tion/860603226

68style 03-20-2025 02:58 PM

Sexy as fuck waking up next to that, bet the missus can't wait to get her bump on

donk. 03-20-2025 03:06 PM

Isnt wrastling a homosexual sport?

https://y.yarn.co/3b5b2592-6d0f-4ccb...d3a4d_text.gif

whitev70r 03-20-2025 03:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 68style (Post 9169920)
Sexy as fuck waking up next to that, bet the missus can't wait to get her bump on

Yah, say goodbye to morning quickies, you'll have to bonk and then put the head strap on and go to sleep.

Ask hehe

mikemhg 03-20-2025 03:23 PM

My GF wears a mouth-guard to bed, that shit ain't sexy at all in the morning..

Hehe 03-20-2025 03:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by whitev70r (Post 9169909)

Mine is a bit more complex than that, but yeah, it's basically the same thing.

Alternative, he also gave me a pack of mouth tapes to keep in the wallet should I go out without my strap. They are 3M and work quite decent as well. But last I heard, it's banned here at least on Amazon. Haha. I had to source them from China.

blkgsr 03-21-2025 11:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PeanutButter (Post 9169908)
Sleep apnea is measured through a different device. Getting one of these health trackers is not going to give you an accurate assessment for sleep apnea. You'll get sleep data, but sleep apnea is a medical condition that needs a CPAP device for proper intervention.

Garmin has the best information for sleep and activities that are free.

Honestly, if you're not going to use it for activities, I don't think it's even necessary.

If you golf, get the Garmin Venu 3, as you get golf distance data + all other activity tracking + sleep tracking. If you don't care about Golf then you should look at the Garmin vivoactive 5, if you use a Sport Chek VIP code you can save about 25% right now.

I never understood the idea of the whoop, it's essentially a watch body without the benefit of a watch.

I think the only one that appeals to me is the ring as that seems kind of cool, but the subscription for it turns me off.

Your best bet is a garmin watch since you don't have an iPhone.

as i mentioned i know expecting a device to track the apnea. I want to track what i heart rate and O2 do in the middle of the night. my heart rate apparently ski rockets and by o2 dropped significantly.

from people at my gym that have the garmins, they aren't good for heart rate tracking. he uses an external device he pairs with it. the garmins don't actually do that good of a job when you look at the comparisons. they are definitely better for the sports uses and GPS etc

6793026 03-24-2025 08:12 AM

FYI, just a HUGE tip for all for sleep apnea.

She was for sure suffering sleep apnea, but since she slept alone, it wasn't until a corp company trip sharing rooms, her roommate said to get tested.

Someone went in for a test and she was border line = won't cover for machine / treatment.

The tech said, come back with the results again, but this time, drink some wine before bed.
Results were off the charts and she got her machine covered by benefits.

Vancouver240sx 03-24-2025 08:54 AM

I have a whoop.

pros:
- The information is pretty robust
- I do like the gamification of the stats if you have friends with it
- The journal feature is probably my favorite aspect which ties in your daily habits to the results
- Its the only watch I found that accurately measured my HR when working out. I used a chest strap for a while but its annoying. Most other watches didn't read past 145ish, but the whoop reads all the way to my max (185 lately).

cons:
- no time display
- subscription model

I purchased the year and don't plan to renew it as I don't feel I'm learning anymore. After a few months of experimenting with what I could change it doesn't surprise me anymore.

Rich

snowball 03-24-2025 11:08 AM

Just remember, if you get the oura ring you need to subscribe to the app monthly even after dropping 400-600 bucks on it...

Jason00S2000 03-24-2025 07:04 PM

Fuck health trackers.

How does your SOUL feel?

6793026 03-25-2025 05:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by snowball (Post 9170353)
Just remember, if you get the oura ring you need to subscribe to the app monthly even after dropping 400-600 bucks on it...

no freaking wayyyy danggggg

blkgsr 03-25-2025 09:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by snowball (Post 9170353)
Just remember, if you get the oura ring you need to subscribe to the app monthly even after dropping 400-600 bucks on it...

ya that was the killer for me with the oura ring.

mikemhg 03-25-2025 09:42 AM

^Late stage capitalism.

Everything is a service, everything is a subscription.

spoon.ek9 03-27-2025 04:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mikemhg (Post 9170531)
^Late stage capitalism.

Everything is a service, everything is a subscription.

I was joking the other day I should start collecting tips after interviewing patients in Emerg lol. It's a service, right? :smug:


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:38 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
SEO by vBSEO ©2011, Crawlability, Inc.
Revscene.net cannot be held accountable for the actions of its members nor does the opinions of the members represent that of Revscene.net