went to try Shimi-Ya on Victoria and 41st today (next to London Drugs) based on reviews from the sushi thread and wasn't disappointed.
the old japanese couple that owns the place are among the nicest people and the food is very fresh.
dragon roll: (unagi with avocado on top)
chopped scallop roll + california roll:
assorted nigiri:
salmon and avocado roll:
i'd give it a 10/10. reasonably priced (around $40 including tip for me and gf, and i was really hungry), great service, and fresh food.
only thing is they are not open sundays and mondays.