[Hondaracer]

Underscore, check out Cavalier in gastown, they deal with lots of different stones other than diamonds and make very nice engagement rings. I've bought jewelry from them before and have been very happy with the service and quality.

Cdizzle, the eBay link leads me to beleive the grading is very poor on the diamond because that is by far the cheapest I've ever seen anything close to that. I also have never heard oft he "clarity treatment" in the description. D color for any other retailer usually means $$$ and for the price, VS2 seems pretty good..

Just seems too good to be true imo compared to almost anywhere else. And as I previously mentioned, personally I wouldn't touch anything but GIA diamonds because the standard can be so different.

If she is set on 1.0CT you may have to make some sacrifices, but for me id probably just set a budget and get the best possible diamond for that budget